June 1, 2013
By Saeed Qureshi
The book of Genesis in Old Testament or Hebrew scripture
Bible has narrated the six days creation saga of the world (not universe). The
unknown writer narrates step by step the actions of God in creating heavens and
earth, followed by light, day and night, then water, then grass and herbs, then
living creatures in the water and dry land and air, and finally man in his own
image.
The writer as witness is watching this unfolding
process of creation by remaining with God for six days. After creating man God
rests on the seventh day. The creation of man is described in Bible in the
following words,” And the lord God formed man of the dust of the ground and
breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living being”.
Amazingly God does not create a female separately but converts one of the ribs
of Adam into woman. The story of serpent misguiding Eve is ridiculous and
interesting as well.
A serpent is living in Garden of Eden (supposed
to be Yemen) and he is able to mislead and prevail upon Eve to eat the
forbidden fruit. Till that time an all knowing God was unaware as to what was
going on in the paradise. He asks Adam how he knew that he was naked and Adam tells
God the whole story. God is annoyed over the fact that Adam had become
knowledgeable.
As a punishment both Adam and Eve are plunged into a life of
toil and hard work to survive. They produce two sons: Cain and Abel. Cain kills
Abel. The apprehension of angels that man would be troublesome proves to be
true.
Islam's story is different. As a punishment for disobeying
God’s commandment not to eat the forbidden fruit, God sends them to earth to
become a perpetual target of Satan whose job is to derail him from the divine
path. The conversation between God, the arch angel Satan and angels is given in
the holy Quran.
God punishes Adam for a minor mistake but gives limitless
powers and freedom to Satan to prey upon the humans. Can God be that much
unjust or making such visibly faulty decisions?
Don’t these two versions look contradictory and
at the same time a fairy tale? Contradictory in the sense that instead
empowering Adam, he bestows his bounties on Satan to be his competitor in disobedience.
After reading these stories the profile of God that comes before us is a simple
and ignorant creator who willingly creates a rival and unleashes him upon his
choice creation.
Now in Islam there is an undeniable logical
rationale for creation of the cosmos, one may interpret as world or the
universe. The God almighty uttered the world Kun (Be) and it became or came
into being (Fayakun).
That command or God’s creative powers do not beg any supplementary
question or query because God as the supreme creator of the universe is capable
of creating anything on the spur of fraction of a second and even in lesser
time. The theory of Big Bang comes closer to this postulation.
What look suspicious or rather frivolous is that
an all powerful God remained busy for six days to create the world. Incidentally
when God started the process of creation there were no days or nights. The days
and nights were created on the third day and therefore the first three days
were practically nonexistent.
The creation process is spawned over a week or so
and at the end God takes a rest as if he is tired and wanted a respite. The
writer forgot that when the days and nights were created on the fourth day, how
we could count for the non-existent three days in the beginning.
That seventh day in Judaism is Sabbath (from
sundown Friday to sundown Saturday) and to follow the tradition of God’s taking
rest on the seventh day, the Jews too lay off on Saturday and do nothing. So
much so that when Jesus Christ was to be buried in a tomb, it was done hastily on
Friday as Sabbath time was about to start.
The Genesis story suggests that besides God there
was someone who was all the time present there and watching and recording the process
of creation taking place. Unless there is s foolproof evidence that someone was
there, how can we accept such a version of creation of the world unless God
himself revealed it to someone?
The Bible both old (Hebrew scripture) and New
Testament (Christian Greek Scripture) were written over a period of 1600 years(
1513 B.C.E. to 98 C.E.) by some 40 writers in various ages. The Old Testament
consists of 39 books and the new 27 books.
It is therefore, an anthology of 66
books altogether. Perhaps the first writer was Prophet Moses (born 1593 B.C.E.)
who passed on the oral laws and written commandments given to him by God on the
Mount Sinai while the Jewish nation was stuck in Sinai desert for 40 years.
After the destruction of the Jerusalem temple by Romans in 70 C.E., the Jews
dispersed and most of them settled in Greece and around Mediterranean. The
Jewish literature and religious books were also destroyed with the destruction
of the temple built by Prophet Solomon the son of Prophet David.
During the next four centuries, under influence
of Greek thought and mythology, the Old Testament was recast and rewritten from
memory or traditions, by Jewish Rabbis and scholars with countless additions
and deletions of the original texts.
The tradition of temple and priesthood
were overshadowed by the oral elucidation, commentaries and explanations of the
Old Testament. The commentaries and complex explanations by rabbis were compiled
into a book that is called Talmud. It is akin to Muslims’ kind of Tafseer or
Hadith.
The Diaspora Jews were enormously influenced by
Greek philosophy and culture and is reflected in Talmud. One such influence was
the belief in immortal soul. It means that when an individual dies his soul should
still live in another place. But the collective resurrection of the dead is
also part of the Bible.
So there seems to be a contradiction between the
collection resurrection on the final day and the concept of immortality of
individual soul. In Bible there is a mention of collective resurrection. The
addition of immortal soul was added in Judaism under the influence of Greek
mythology.
Islam has resolved this tangle by espousing that
the dead man’s soul rests in purgatory (Barzakh) and would come back to each
person and they would come to life again. There is a strong possibility that during
their interaction with Greek culture, religious dogmas and philosophy, the Genesis
and other chapters were rewritten by Jewish scholars. The first five books in
the Old Testament including Genesis are called Torah.
On the
face, the creation of the world in six days and making of Adam with bare hands looks
to be the invention of a fictional and fanciful mind without realizing that it
derides and belittles a God, who in all faiths is and ought to be omnipotent,
omniscient and omnipresent.
How could he soil his hands in the dust? How is God
supposed to be using hands and breathing like a human? How the lord of the
world gets tired and rests on the 7th day? These are some critical questions
that come to a curious mind?
The Genesis can best be described as a fable
written for the children or the credulous, colored with suspense and fantasy.
It is utterly hard for the people of this age to accept it as a rational and
absolute truth. It is funny, frivolous and untenable. It underlines the limited
human traits of a creator who otherwise is managing this amazing universe with
absolutely flawless scientific principles.
The evolution is central to this
universe and that can be the true explanation for an ever changing world. How the
existence or creation started, through a big bang or some other way: we do not
know. But certainly the story of Genesis in Torah is not an answer to that gigantic
question.
Sikh scripture says that like a son can not know of the birth event of his father so the man can not know about the birth of God's creation. Thus, the present day knowledge is all guess work and hypotheses. Let us spend our time on thinking about NOW.
ReplyDeleteI really appreciate your cogent comment. Present is the most important phase of life. But more than that it is the future. Present is always in a state of flux and is fleeting. it is in fact future in transition. The present moment becomes future the very next moment.
ReplyDelete